Celtic Chalk Talk Special: Shock and Fallout From the Jaylen Brown Trade to Philly
Steve Purciello and co-host Jose Salviati react in disbelief and frustration to Boston trading Jaylen Brown to the rival 76ers, calling the return inadequate for a Finals MVP in his prime who led a 56-win season and is praised for leadership, clutch moments, defense, and community impact. They discuss how analytics may have depressed Brown’s perceived value, but argue it misses his “winner” qualities and big-shot ability. Steve suggests cap/CBA concerns and a looming expensive extension may have driven Boston to reset, leaving the Celtics as a mid-tier playoff team unless further moves follow, while speculating Payton Pritchard could replace some scoring. They also note Philadelphia could be formidable if Embiid stays healthy, creating a painful outlook for Celtics fans.
00:00 Shock Trade Reaction
00:20 Podcast Network Intro
00:51 Jose Joins In
01:12 Trading With Philly
02:31 Brown Legacy Moments
05:14 Analytics Versus Eye Test
08:58 Contract And CBA Pressure
10:00 Celtics Outlook After Deal
11:49 Course Correction Debate
13:17 Sixers Fit And Contenders
14:33 Rivals And League Chaos
15:28 Final Wrap Up
Steve Purciello and co-host Jose Salviati react in disbelief and frustration to Boston trading Jaylen Brown to the rival 76ers, calling the return inadequate for a Finals MVP in his prime who led a 56-win season and is praised for leadership, clutch moments, defense, and community impact. They discuss how analytics may have depressed Brown’s perceived value, but argue it misses his “winner” qualities and big-shot ability. Steve suggests cap/CBA concerns and a looming expensive extension may have driven Boston to reset, leaving the Celtics as a mid-tier playoff team unless further moves follow, while speculating Payton Pritchard could replace some scoring. They also note Philadelphia could be formidable if Embiid stays healthy, creating a painful outlook for Celtics fans.
00:00 Shock Trade Reaction
00:20 Podcast Network Intro
00:51 Jose Joins In
01:12 Trading With Philly
02:31 Brown Legacy Moments
05:14 Analytics Versus Eye Test
08:58 Contract And CBA Pressure
10:00 Celtics Outlook After Deal
11:49 Course Correction Debate
13:17 Sixers Fit And Contenders
14:33 Rivals And League Chaos
15:28 Final Wrap Up
Celtic Chalk Talk - Trade Reaction
===
Steve: [00:00:00] Welcome to a special edition of Celtic Chalk Talk. I'm in shock right now about the Jaylen Brown trade. A little quite upset and disappointed in Boston for doing it. But my name's Steve Purciello. I've been doing this for this year. Celtic fan forever, go back to the Bill Russell days. Don't remember a trade like this in my life.
And before I even begin, I just wanna mention something. If you like this podcast, it's on the Peach Basket network of podcasts. There are a whole bunch of them, independent fans of basketball. They talk basketball. They are not affiliated with teams in any official manner, but they have opinions and thoughts like mine, probably better, and I would suggest sincerely that you go look it up and listen to some of them.
You'll enjoy it, and there's various teams covered within it. Today... Usually I do this by myself. Today I'm going to do it with my partner, Jose Salviati who does our other [00:01:00] Shot Clock pod together. We do it together. And he's from out in Los Angeles, so he's got a different view, and I wanna hear as well as say things about it.
Jose, what do you got?
Jose: I'll start with the same reaction you had. When when I heard about it, I was shocked. Number one, the fact that you trade with Philly is shocking, right? Short of the Lakers, that is the Celtics' number one rival. And you generally don't, y- you don't work with your rivals that way.
I don't know how many historic trades there have been between the two franchises, but I guess it wouldn't be too many, and certainly none like this. So n- that was number one shock. The number two shock is what they got. It's shocking to me. Jaylen Brown is, y- at the peak of his career.
He's not somebody who's declining. You saw that last year. He took a team that nobody expected to do any- to do anything, and he took them to the number two spot. I think you mentioned 56 wins. They fizzled a little in the playoffs, [00:02:00] but he led that team.
This is a Finals MVP, for goodness sakes. This is a very good player. The fact that they couldn't get more for for him and kinda had to, and now I'm just being really subjective here in my opinion here. But they kinda had to settle for the Philadelphia's offer.
Th- that I... There's no way that was the number one offer they had on their whiteboard.
They had to settle for that. It's shocking. It's just absolutely shocking. But yeah, that that's my knee-jerk
Steve: Before and I have a lot of thoughts that I've been still trying to process, but I'm gonna say a couple things about Jaylen Brown. First of all, is a winner. A true winner, and I go in my mind, I go back when he came to the Celtics, the number three pick, fans booed it. What are you doing?
Brad Stevens in the beginning would pull him whenever he made a mistake, and it was rough time. But you know what? I also saw him grow into a really good player and a leader in a lot of ways. And I [00:03:00] think about the game I think about the Indiana game in the final, in the s- sec- conference finals a couple years ago when the first game they're down by what?
A point or two with very little time out, and he hits a three out of the corner, falling out of bounds almost and wins the game for them. Boston goes on to sweep that series. Then he takes care of Luka and does a great job and really by pressuring him full court. Luka basically gave up in that series and Boston won that series easily in five games. This year, what did he do? He took a team, and I know we can get into the analytics and we will, but this team, without Jason Tatum, won 56 games. But to really put it in perspective, they lost Porziņģis, they lost Holiday, they lost Horford. Three guys who were part of a champion, and they came up with guys getting $2 million a year, not compared to those guys, but two million, and they won 56 games with leading the way. [00:04:00] second team should've been first team. We can argue that for another time. Jaylen Brown is tough. Think about the finals against this year with-- not finals, but the series with Ph- Philly. Jaylen Brown, Boston couldn't stop Embiid. The Nets, I've always talked that Boston needed a thicker guy, and they might have that with Mitchell Robinson. But they didn't have that. Jaylen Brown said, "Give him to me. I'll guard him." He wasn't successful, but think of the heart and also think of a star player willing to go out and possibly embarrass himself, but he didn't care because he was there to win. And it says so much about him, and that's why my emotions, got to me because this guy's number is gonna be retired in Boston,
and this guy is revered in Boston because of all the money he puts out for kids and everything else he does in the city. This is-- it makes absolutely no sense. I'm hoping that Brad Ste-- not Brad. Yeah, [00:05:00] Brad Stevens has something else in, in
Jose: Right
Steve: meaning there's a follow-up. If there isn't I wanna hear him address it. But that's my emotion. There's a lot more to talk about. Jose, you want to add anything with that?
Jose: May- maybe just a couple thoughts. A- again, as you mentioned I'm kinda the outsider here. I'm based on based in LA so I get things, from a different perspective. I think number one, y- you guys have got a... And when you say you guys, I'm talking about the Boston Celtics, right?
The Boston Celtics have got a front office that has proven to be adept at what they do. So when you see something like this is a one- this might be a one-off, this might be a mistake, or it could be step one in something, a grand scheme that makes sense over time. Brad Stevens, is somebody who I wouldn't be surprised, had, has his plan B, plan C.
Or not plan B and C, but really next step two, step three, step four. So l- let's start there, right? A- as a Celtics fan, I wouldn't [00:06:00] panic yet although this does seem pretty jarring. The other thing, the whole conversation around analytics and stuff I think it's it all begins with Bobby Marks' tweet.
And he said not too long ago that Jaylen Brown was the seventh best player on a team. And analytics bear that out. I s- I saw a tweet somewhere and I would give credit if I knew where it came from. I don't. But that his... A- and this is last season's team. His plus/minus was -7 or -5. So essentially when he was on the court, and this is for a 56-win team that he led he gave up more points than he scored.
Now obviously it's not just Jaylen Brown, but it's everybody else around him. So those the analytics tell a quirky story about a very good player. But then your point is, you, what the analytics don't tell you is the heart of the guy, right? The eye test, wh- you, which I think is something you said earlier before.
And the eye test is clear. This guy's a winner. This guy wants to win, and this guy's gonna do [00:07:00] everything he can to win. And the analytics don't show that. So did analytics have a play here, right? Did somebody look and not, and I'm not just saying the Celtics in looking to move on from him, but in people who had an opportunity to get him.
The Clippers were interested at least what we heard out here in LA. There was interest i- in, in, in in Jaylen Brown here for the LA Clippers. Did they look at the analytics and say, "Ah, yeah, we're better off with Brandon Ingram"? Maybe. I don't know. That, that is shocking to me.
The value the most jarring thing I think is the value that Jaylen Brown has. This is a Finals MVP. This is a winner. I get the analytics piece, but the analytics don't tell the whole story. They tell a story not the whole story. So that's the only thing I would interject. I understand as a Celtics fan, it's jarring to see somebody who was again the Finals MVP, leave, and leave for nothing.
Not, I shouldn't say for nothing, but leave for very little is [00:08:00] jarring. But I do think that you guys have got a f- a team and a front office that has gotta have a plan. This can't be it. Mitchell Robinson and Paul George cannot be it for the Boston Celtics
Steve: First of all, and there's a whole bunch of things from what you said to talk about. The analytics thing is very big on basketball. But I haven't seen an a- a stat or whatever on guys making big shots.
If you tell me that y- 60% of the time a 15-footer goes in, that's great. But does it, does a player make it with five seconds left on the clock? That's a whole different part of the game. And guys are winners and guys aren't. He's a winner. So the analytics stuff I... sometimes it makes sense 'cause, it does make sense. The corner three is a higher percentage, and you look at the numbers. So you want guys shooting out of the corner.
There's certain parts of analytics that are worthwhile. But to me, he's good. And now I just [00:09:00] wanna get into one thing or two things that I think caused it. Jaylen Brown's got three years on his contract. Now, Boston was dealing or working a deal twice now, two years ago for Durant and now. Or three years, whatever it was for Durant. And then with this year with Giannis. Boston, it all fell through, had to come through and ma- basically, at the end of July, give him a two-year extension at 70 million a year. That would've given him five more years. But now think about it, 35 years old making 70 million a year. You're not winning when that big part of
your overall salary cap is spending on him. Boston might've been looking at that and
Jose: Sure
Steve: it doesn't work. Now, that's the CBA problem. The CBA problem is because you can't keep these guys as they get older, and you have to trade them, and that's not fair to the fans, but I've talked about that already. But that's one thing that I just wanted to [00:10:00] mention.
Now, where does it leave the Celtics? Besides me, a heartbroken Celtics fan, it leaves the Celtics as a mid-level playoff team, meaning fifth, sixth type team. That's great, but they're not good enough. Now, if they kept Jaylen Brown, they still weren't what I would consider a title contender because of the drop-off in the rest of the team and the question mark about Jayson Tatum.
So they had to go out and improve the team. They had to go out improve the team to have a chance at a title They probably looked at it as trading Jalen will help them reset. That's the only way I can-- if, unless there's another deal. The only way I can figure it out. There's one other piece that I just wanna add, and I've read a little bit. is thinking, Payton Pritchard averaged 17 points a year game this year. They're thinking they watched another 6'2" or 6'1" guy take over the league this year in Jalen Brunson. They have to be [00:11:00] thinking this guy will fill in the points for Jaylen Brown, because I don't know how else you're going to get it. And the last point, they are-- And Brown was a very good defender, but they still will be a very good, better defensive team because of Mitchell Robinson
And Kader being able to play. But to me, you just-- if that's the best you can get you're telling me after all these weeks, Paul George was the best offer you got. I'm having a rough time.
I'm having a rough time and I'm sorry to see Jaylen go. That's not Celtic tradition. Celtic tradition, even when Pierce and Garnett were traded Danny Ainge asked that they didn't mind getting dealt. This, you're just getting a guy out of there that won you a title makes no sense. But that's my thoughts. Jose, anything you wanna
Jose: Y- yeah, didn't you and I just have a conversation though about the mistakes that the '80 Celtics made in keeping Bird and Parish a little too long, right? [00:12:00] We just had that conversation. So i- is this course correcting then? They didn't make the same mistake with Jaylen Brown
Steve: I believe that the idea would be to deal the guy before, he's worth nothing. But he's worth nothing. Paul George in a number one pick, 36-year-old Paul George, he's worth nothing now. And you could always sit there and say, "Jalen, you got three years left. We're not gonna pay you anymore after that." That's the way it's gonna be. Tell your agent to find a deal. But the way it was handled, and Brad Stevens is a class act. The way it was handled, it just it, it just smells. It's terrible. As a Celtic fan, I'll be back but it's not fun. It's not a fun thing
Jose: How do you think he's going to be welcomed in his first game back wearing a Sixers jersey?
Steve: There's going to be, unless something else comes down, they are-- First of all, they have the tribute.
There's gonna be some people upset, but they're gonna be cheering only for Jaylen Brown. They're [00:13:00] going to be cheering heavily for him because he was so
Jose: Yeah
Steve: They're not gonna be cheering they're not gonna be booing.
They're gonna be-- because then they're gonna thank him for what he did. Boston people are very tradition-oriented, and they will thank him for the greatness. I do wanna add one thing, though. wonder how many basketballs-- Philadelphia could be great if Embiid's healthy, but I wonder how many basketballs they're go-going to need. They've got four guys that can put the ball in the basket.
Jose: Yeah
Steve: And if they can work through that, they've got a shot at the whole... And if Embiid's healthy, they got a shot at the whole
Jose: Yeah, we talked, and this is a Boston show, so obviously we talked about the Celtics, but the Sixers look pretty darn good right now. E- even without Embiid. Em- Embiid, y- you mark him down for 30, 40 games, right? I'll be happy with that. But they've got... They're small, obviously, without Embiid, but they've got some really talented players.
Maxey is phenomenal. Edgecomb is phenomenal. And now they got Jalen Brown. Th- [00:14:00] that's a pretty dominant trio. Sixers might be pretty good next year
Steve: I think they could be. If Embiid plays enough, they could be. And all you need in a kid like Barlow as their four, he's perfect. He doesn't wanna shoot, and he'll do all the dirty work. So they, they've got everything. The biggest question they have would be can Embiid become the presence at the basket defensively? really doesn't rebound
well
Jose: Yeah
Steve: and he doesn't he doesn't, protect the rim real well anymore. So that's a big question. But you know what? There's nothing more painful for a Celtic fan than seeing Philadelphia do okay and the Knicks win a title.
Jose: I was just
Steve: you know what's
Jose: gonna say
Steve: It's almost a reversal.
The Knicks have always been incompetent. Now they're the competent ones, and Boston was always competent. Now they're in-- now it appears they're incompetent. So it's been a rough couple weeks, let's put
it
Jose: what we need is the trifecta and the Lakers to maybe deal for Nikola [00:15:00] Jokic, and then all of a sudden your world, your whole world is turned upside down
Steve: Don't even don't even think that. That's just... they just paid a lot of money for Walker Kessler
I... god bless
Jose: Yeah
Steve: Anyway and they are better.
Jose: I think so too.
Steve: team.
Jose: I, they're certainly a lot more exciting
Steve: Eh, who cares? They can't beat San Antonio or
Jose: No.
No.
Steve: It, it will be more entertaining.
Jose: agree
Steve: considering with the Clippers down, the Lakers will draw
Jose: yeah
Steve: the f- the fandom will be back. But anyway, that, that wraps it up. It's a special edition. Jose, thank you,
Jose: Purse
Steve: take care, people.
It's been a rough one


